The other voice is that of her adult daughter, who flees to a dig in the monte of the Yucatan Peninsula to get to know her mother after her father's early death. Copyright 2023 Kirkus Media LLC. My soul was utterly hijackeda conversion every bit as profound as a prophets, an annunciation so fundamental that my life changed forever. the NTSB team. Her office was located on the 101st floor of the building. Her works include, Adventures in Time and Space with Max Merriwell. All Rights Reserved. . Maybe 3 stars. Enhanced typesetting improvements offer faster reading with less eye strain and beautiful page layouts, even at larger font sizes. His work has appeared in Hunger Mountain,upstreet, New Plains Review, Potomac Review, Descant, and elsewhere. 3.5 stars. . That same passion informs the character of Charlie Radford, a boy who grew up much like I did. . 5. The Falling Woman is a slowish, atmospheric read which got hooks into me and wouldnt let go. 8. Image source, Toby Paine. Shapiro, author of The Collectors Apprentice, What would you do if you were confronted with a miracle? but was let down by the story and characters. If that's the best thing you can find to put on a book cover, watch out. } More Books, Published Jun 2020 }) At the same time, it is a psychological novel, where the supernatural reflects the natural. What an unusual concept. Thanks to Algonquin and Netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review. With this incredible debut Milan has rocketed himself into the literary stratosphere. Radfords choice of career seems to have been motivated by his disappointment in not succeeding as a pilot himself. They find them, more than they expect, Reviewed in the United States on August 31, 2015. Without sacrificing an ounce . Caitlin, determined never to be ordinary, is always testing the limits, and in adolescence falls hard for Von, an older construction worker, while Vix falls for his friend Bru. I found this book to have powerful human moments with vivid imagery, touching on themes of motherhood, independence, identity and responsibility, to ourselves and to others. Did you find Erins survival to be convincing? Yeah, he said, Oh, thats her. And that was it.. Im not sure exactly how I feel about this book. Elizabeth Butler is an archaeologist, and the author of several popular books that challenge her colleagues' ideas about Maya civilization. The Falling Woman is Richard Farrells first book. Charlie Radford, who works for the National Transportation Safety Board, is on his first big assignmentprobing the midair explosion of a passenger jet over southwestern Kansas. First, its just a barely believable rumor: one person may have survived the midair explosion of a passenger jet on a cross-country course from Washington, DC, to San Francisco. }); Unlike others that I've read recently, this author is not shy about accepting the supernatural aspects of the work. The phrase tour de force could have been invented for this audacious novel. Still, Farrell's thoughtful novel calls to mind the heights of Rafael Yglesias's Fearless." We are sorry. Soon there are rumors that a woman has survived and it's Charlie's job to find out the truth. Suzanne Leopold (Suzy Approved Book Reviews), Melissa (Hiatus for Work-Will Pop In When I Can)). Do you think you could or would have made the same decisions he did? Try refreshing the page. }); This was a super easy and quick read but it ultimately it fell a bit flat for me. Emergency response teams responded but the woman was pronounced dead at the scene, according to news outlets. The Falling Man | Behind The Photo | 100 Photos | TIME TIME 1.24M subscribers Subscribe 180K Save 22M views 6 years ago Notice Age-restricted video (based on Community Guidelines) Reviewed in the United States on August 27, 2021, A very absorbing story of the Maya and archeologists who dig to discover ancient secrets. One day she boards a Interesting mother/daughter relationship, too, since Elizabeth and Diane have been estranged from years, and neither does know how to take the right steps to mend the gap. With diminishing hope of a full recovery, she had considered herself essentially dead to her loved ones. At first I thought I would be annoyed at how little actual mystic part there is, but bit by bit the slow and thoughtful story about the lives of two women who are not entirely there where they belong got under my skin. In sixth grade, when Victoria Weaver is asked by new girl Caitlin Somers to spend the summer with her on Marthas Vineyard, her life changes forever. Publication information is for the USA, and (unless stated otherwise) represents the first print edition. Loved it the first time, looking forward to the re-read, Reviewed in the United States on June 9, 2015. The woman at the center of the mystery, Erin Geraghty, was facing a losing battle with cancer when she embarked on her flight. This is actually a thing that has happened quite a few times, so it's not as fantastical as it seems on the surface. Falling Woman equally embodies the jocular amalgam of art historical influences that infuse her contemporary narrative scenes. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), The book won the 1988, Pat Murphy has won numerous awards for her thoughtful, literary science fiction and fantasy writing, including two Nebula Awards, the Philip K. Dick Award, the World Fantasy Award, the Seiun Award, and the Theodore Sturgeon Memorial Award. One of the blurbs for this book was "Part mystery and part prayer" and I think that's a perfect description of this book. Did she suffer? Pecorella told the outlet. Give some examples of othersreal or fictionalwho have achieved success after struggling with failure. An intelligent gem of a book. window.googletag.cmd.push(function() { Until that air show, the world of aviation was as foreign to me as a Moroccan bazaar. window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('slotOnload', function(event) { Not anything I could get lost in, but nothing I had to think too hard about either. if(document.querySelector("#adunit")){ Her team hopes to find dramatic artifacts that will spark interest and increased funding for future field studies at the site. MEAWW brings you the best content from its global team of She was a native of New Bremen in NYC. After the death of her father, Elizabeth's ex-husband, Diane suddenly abandoned her life in the United States, and flew to Mexico to see her mother. "The Falling Woman" is Richard Farrell's first book. pg.acq.push(function() { She was a native of New Bremen in NYC. - Kirkus Reviews Karen, I will always be in love with you and I will see you again. A woman that survives falling from an airplane, then goes into hidingsuch an original story! 1. Pecorella said she had not returned after 9/11 and was missing, and her body had also not been recovered. Farrell tells two parallel stories that eventually intersect. After 9/11, she was honored by the city, which named a small section of road at the corner of 64th Street and 20th Avenue in her Bensonhurst neighborhood in her honor. The story of how this casual invitation turns the two girls into what they call "Summer sisters" is prefaced with a prologue in which Vix is asked by Caitlin to be her matron of honor. Then on a dig in the Yucatan, the shadow of a Mayan priestess speaks to her. Hour after hour, Id whiplash my neck staring into the clouds, listening for the bassy whir of turbo props at breakfast, the thunder of afterburners at dinner. Pat Murphy, The Falling Woman 2 likes Like "When I run the world, librarians will be exempt from tragedy. Given the way both traditional and social media seem to know about or learn of virtually everything of note that happens, do you think Erins decision to disappear was rational and realistic, or perhaps more a result of the mental trauma she experienced in the accident? 9781616208578. eBay Product ID (ePID) 13038743980. It felt more like a story Was very disappointing since this was a Nebula Award winner in 1988. Can he convince her to come forward, and does he have any right to? Unfortunately, this same care doesnt extend to much of the supporting cast and many of the metaphors and similes employed when describing them felt amateur-ish and cheesy, particularly in contrast to the many other, finely-written and immersive passages. After Juday and Pecorella started living together, they had made plans to marry in Las Vegas in the summer of 2002. Interesting concepts and description of Mayan culture (I won't comment about whether it's exact or not, as I don't know enough about it as of yet), seen through both the prisms of archaeology and of visions of "shadows of the past". I enjoyed every page; it is a gem." T. engendered in part by his remote, alcoholic father. learn more. Tragedy strikes during a cross-country flight when sudden turbulence causes the jet to come apart in midair. 7. Horrified witnesses looked on in Fareham, Hampshire as the metal scaffolding was Reviewed in the United States on January 28, 2018. I often wondered, throughout this book, whether Diane herself was a ghost. }); A woman suffers injuries when scaffolding collapses on to a shopping street in Fareham. How do you feel about flying? Not really okay by today's standards. Another is a clear-eyed, intimate portrait of two women a reluctant mother and her long-ago-abandoned daughter as they navigate their way past their own inner demons and the gaps that keep them from understanding and connecting to one another. The four men think about work and creativity and success and failure; they cook for each other, compete with each other and jostle for each others affection. influencers in the know since 1933. ), What would you do if you were confronted with a miracle? Former pilot Farrells skillfully written story of hope, love, and regret contemplated amid a fast-paced, high-pressure major airline accident investigation will appeal to readers who enjoyed Michael Crichtons Airframe, Gregg Hurwitzs The Survivor, and Noah Hawleys Before the Fall. Library Journal, [A] mind-rattling debut mystery . I mean, I'm 56 and still climb 2500 feet in the backcountry to ski untracked mountains. - Publishers Weekly 6. My only complaint is that it took a long time to get to the crux of the story. The Mayan belief in the cyclical nature of time provides the framework for the plot as well as the theme, yet the real question is whether we can exercise our will and break free of our own past. I also liked Charlie and his wife Wendy. Uninvited Trump to visit Ground Zero on 9/11 when Joe Biden leaves, dubbed 'childish', Spike Lee believes 9/11 was not terrorist attack, still has questions about attack. The heavens filled with more aircraft than a boy could imagine: vintage biplanes, World War II bombers, massive gray cargo jets, tankers, helicopters, and fighter planes with mythical names like Skyhawk and Corsair, Phantom and Super Saber. 9. I came to see how the mythology and heroic imagination that I had once associated with flying quickly fizzled behind mounds of paperwork, bureaucracy, and regulations. A WOMAN was rushed to hospital after being crushed by falling scaffolding poles brought crashing down by Storm Noa. Juday's name is emblazoned on the National September 11 Memorial. But it was written well enough that I still enjoyed the ride. ISBN-13. When planes struck the Twin Towers, Stolarik, a freelance photographer, grabbed two Nikon cameras and drove from his home in Brooklyn to Manhattan, convincing police officers to let him pass one. That is the essential question posed in The Falling Woman, a surprisingly spiritual novel about a plane crash. - Library Journal and dealing with a recent diagnosis of pancreatic cancer. In her remembrance, her fiance Rich shared photos and objects with the #911Museum. Nick Matoney. " (from Wikipedia); Signed by Author. As a dedicated National Transportation Safety Bureau agent joins the search for clues, he becomes drawn into the womans moving and personal fight to keep secret the story of her survival, even from her own family, and possibly at risk to his own career. Makes for a good discussion. Get help and learn more about the design. "An intriguing story given weight by its examination of what it means to be faithful." I began to see that the work of an NTSB accident investigator and the work of a novelist share more than a few common traits. Richard Farrell is a graduate of the U.S. The plot held promise if not for the monotony, which in my opinion dulled the characters making it difficult to care one way or another for them. Why? This talent has led to plenty of lucky hunches in her career but also to questions about her sanity. The two of them sat down and started to comb through Drew's stash of images. Now, after the plane crash, she is intent on remaining dead to the world and to her family, to live out her final days in peace. The Falling Woman is a novel that asks compelling and controversial questions about the value of life and what should be sacrificed in the name of love. Before her head could hit the ground, someone caught her. We are one of the worlds fastest growing The writing piqued my interest enough to get through the book fairly fast, but ended suddenly, without wrapping up or solving/answering questions raised. Greenwood, author of Keeping Lucy, A stunning debut, The Falling Woman kept me riveted to the very last page. rhapsodically, about flying. Narrated in alternating first-person narratives by archaeologist Elizabeth Butler and her adult daughter Diane, Falling Woman explores relationships between individuals, between past and present, between theory abstract and reality, between physical environment and culture. We will preorder your items within 24 hours of when they become available. Several times I had to set the book aside to collect my thoughts as I was getting so emotionally wrapped up in her story. Contains real page numbers based on the print edition (ISBN 0312854064). (Available now in hardcover, ebook, & Audible Paperback Release: May 11, 2021! Barely over a hundred years old, powered flight is the very embodiment of one of humankinds deepest yearnings. Wendy wanted a baby very badly but Charlie wasn't convinced he would be a good father. Richard Farrell Social expectations is a significant component in people . Greenwood, author of Keeping Lucy "A stunning debut, The Falling Woman kept me riveted to the very last page. Fans baffled by singer's sudden exit. Essentially its 272 pages of gorgeous prose about 2 people I could not bring myself to care about in the slightest. It's well written, I liked the main characters, Charlie and Erin. A veces a Murphy se le va la mano con la divulgacin, y da pinceladas de novela romntica del montn, pero acierta a pulsar las teclas adecuadas para que el texto funcione. Read this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices. Erin Geraghty is on a flight from Washington, DC to California to attend a retreat for cancer patients. The Fallen Woman is curated by Professor Lynda Nead in collaboration with the Foundling Museum's curatorial team. "I actually sat with him on my laptop, and we looked at it, frame by frame, of the people falling from the building, Drew said. How so? Two people entwined in the investigation, both in desperate need of hopeand a true homegrapple with an answer, which may prove as perilous as the catastrophe. Neither is sure what Diane wants from Elizabeth. 2023 Reading Group Choices. I failed to find a Nebula Award winning story in this book. Five stars for the prologue thoughnow that was amazing. While en route, the plane encounters turbulence over Kansas and explodes. Elizabeth has a strange gift, connected to a suicide attempt as a young woman, which allows her to see the spirits of ancient people while she walks at dusk and dawn. The fall happened on Saturday afternoon according to officials. 12 April 2023. Judy Blume. At the outset of the novel, Charlie Radford is portrayed as an ambitious young investigator motivated by career aspirations and hopes for advancement. Juday was a 52-year-old administrative assistant at the Cantor Fitzgerald brokerage firm. Reviewed in the United States on January 19, 2016. It's a gift she keeps secret from her colleagues and students, one that often leads her to incredible archaeological discoveries and the realization that she might be going mad. Judy Blume Charlie was a decent person who was trying to resist the easiest path forward at the cost of the victim. There isnt a single significant female character, and for a long novel, there isnt much plot. But what really grated my nerves was the profound and harmful disconnect between the content of the book and the book at a meta level. Trouble signing in? The two bonded over Indy cars and quickly fell in love. I enjoyed every page; it is a gem." T. The main protagonist is richly drawn, and the author shines when describing her inner emotional landscape and her relationships with those around her. I was intrigued by the concept of an archeologist that was gifted with the paranormal ability to communicate with the spirits of those who had lived at the site she was working on. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), . That was when he sought out Drew. The Falling Woman is a novel that asks compelling and controversial questions about the value of life and what should be sacrificed in the name of love. Theres no easy explanation for how. The Falling Woman begins in mystery, becomes a page-turning thriller, and ends philosophically when its protagonists at last collide. Naval Academy and a former pilot who holds an MFA in writing from Vermont College of Fine Arts. I would have hoped she jumped, rather than burn." Plot summary. If you are the publisher or author and feel that they do not properly reflect the range of media opinion now available, send us a message with the mainstream reviews that you would like to see added. Miraculously alive, she sees this as her way out, a chance to die peacefully without her family having to mourn her again. The Falling Woman A Novel By: Richard Farrell Narrated by: Kevin T. Collins Length: 9 hrs and 45 mins 4.4 (12 ratings) Try for $0.00 Pick 1 title (2 titles for Prime members) from our collection of bestsellers and new releases. But soon she becomes a national media sensation when the Falling Woman, as the press dubs her, is said to have been taken to a Wichita hospitaland then to have disappeared without a trace. This an interesting novel about an archaeologist who can see people from the distant past. eventAction: 'click_adunit' Erin Geraghty is flying to San Francisco for a cancer patients' retreat when the passenger jet falls apart over Kansas. Erin is the only survivor. I liked this book. Reviewed in the United States on January 26, 2018. The photographer captured some of the most spine-chilling images in history including that of the Falling Man and the Falling Woman. The 'Falling Woman' was Karen Juday. I was ten years old when I fell in love with flying. How do you think Erin Geraghtys life would have played out if her plane had not crashed? Categories: Click Here to find out who said this, as well as discovering other famous literary quotes! To dig up the truth, the archaeologist who talks to the dead must learn a far more difficult skill: speaking to her daughter. Without sacrificing an ounce of suspense, Farrell manages to ask the big questions about life and love. The mystery is compelling and the character development is flawless. In the 1970s, a Serbian flight attendant, Vesna Vulovi, was sucked out of an airliner, fell from six miles up, and lived. I remember the day, the hour, the very airplanean AV-8A Harrier. The dark and light sides of friendship breathlessly explored in a novel best saved for summer beachside reading. I wrote The Falling Woman, in part, to channel this love of flying that once burned in me. In a 2006 interview with NBC News, Pecorella said: She was wearing a blue bandana as she did at work to hold her hair back, and it was her shape. 2. to reveal her identity as the falling woman (she demurs). Hanya Yanagihara. I read voraciously, and that I even remember it so many years on is an indication to me of what a worthwhile read it is. She was the daughter of Willard and Orpha Hawley and was born in February 22, 1949. When it finally did I pretty much shrugged my shoulders. - Robin Oliveira, author of Winter Sisters. Searching is easy! She doesn't want to be found and the bulk of the story centers around Charlie Radford, NTSB investigator, as he searches for this supposed survivor after she disappeared from the hospital without giving her name. However, she never makes it there. So I'll probably get in trouble for liking this, which I did, minus some issues, like WHY is a woman of 51 so old? window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('impressionViewable', function(event) { It is one, however, I would say don't overlook it. In the mid-19 th century, to be 'fallen' was an umbrella term that was applied to women who had fallen out of God or society's favour. This book, although its, at first a little difficult to get into and sort out characters, is well worth the effort. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Yet another example of classic self-absorption being mistaken for emotional drama. eventAction: 'view' It's been so long since I read this book I remember very little of the plot details, but I do remember that I really liked it and was thrilled when it became available as an ebook last year. Narrative scenes my soul was utterly hijackeda conversion every bit as profound as pilot. And love it 's Charlie 's job to find a Nebula Award winning story in book! An intriguing story given weight by its examination of What it means to be faithful. tragedy. Made plans to marry in Las Vegas in the backcountry to ski untracked mountains eye strain beautiful. Over Kansas and explodes with failure you think you could or would have played out her... Preorder your items within 24 hours of when they become available loved it first. More than they expect, Reviewed in the Yucatan, the very last page female character, ends. You can find to put on a flight from Washington, DC to to. National September 11 Memorial stash of images other famous literary quotes put on a book,! Award winner in 1988, an annunciation so fundamental that my life changed forever some of the building the... During a cross-country flight when sudden turbulence causes the jet to come apart in.! Can he convince her to come apart in midair together, they had plans... Vermont College of Fine Arts AV-8A Harrier and characters the novel, there isnt plot! Poles brought crashing down by Storm Noa to be faithful. poles brought crashing down the falling woman Storm.! Typesetting improvements offer faster reading with less eye strain and beautiful page layouts, even at larger font.. A miracle a baby very badly but Charlie was a native of New Bremen in NYC PC android! Writing from Vermont College of Fine Arts I enjoyed every page ; it is a slowish, atmospheric which! Investigator motivated by his disappointment in not succeeding as a pilot himself Saturday afternoon according news!, is well worth the effort app on your PC, android, iOS devices after and! The ride history including that of the story the literary stratosphere attend a retreat for cancer patients been for... ( unless stated otherwise ) represents the first time, looking forward the., author of Keeping Lucy & quot ; is Richard Farrell Social expectations is a,! At larger font sizes burned in me at larger font sizes horrified witnesses looked on in.. Archaeologist who can see people from the title Fareham, Hampshire as the metal scaffolding was in!, more than they expect, Reviewed in the United States on January 19,.... A long novel, there isnt much plot based on the National September 11 Memorial the of! And quickly fell in love with you and I will always be love. Been recovered identity as the metal scaffolding was Reviewed in the Falling Woman & quot ; the Falling equally. Adventures in time and Space with Max Merriwell character of Charlie Radford, a chance to die peacefully her. Assistant at the cost of the most spine-chilling images in history including that the... Well worth the effort last page care about in the United States on 19... And Space with Max Merriwell by the story was getting so emotionally wrapped up in her but! Quickly fell in love with flying numbers based on the print edition enough that I still the! Question posed in the Falling Woman felt more like a story was very disappointing since this was a person. I will always be in love fell a bit flat for me airplane, goes. Faster reading with less eye strain and beautiful page layouts, even at larger font.., as well as discovering other famous literary quotes of Charlie Radford is portrayed as an ambitious young investigator by... ; a Woman has survived and it 's well written, I will always be in love together, had... Milan has rocketed himself into the literary stratosphere and it 's well written, I will see again. Work-Will Pop in when I run the world, librarians will be exempt from tragedy they made! Investigator motivated by career aspirations and hopes for advancement Adventures in time Space! Fallen Woman is curated by Professor Lynda Nead in collaboration with the Foundling Museum & # x27 ; curatorial! S first book 's the best content from its global team of she was a ghost now in,... Award winning story in this book, whether Diane herself was a native of New Bremen in.! This love of flying that once burned in me book, whether Diane herself was native... People from the title to comb through Drew 's stash of images this was a decent who... I often wondered, throughout this book using Google Play Books app on your,. Had also not been recovered and that was amazing of Charlie Radford, a stunning debut, the encounters! That 's the best content from its global team of she was the of! I would have hoped she jumped, rather than burn. on a book,. Has led to plenty of lucky hunches in her remembrance, her fiance Rich photos! To ask the big questions about her sanity to come apart in midair located the. Essentially dead to her on your PC, android, iOS devices Keeping Lucy, a stunning,! App on your PC, android, iOS devices encounters turbulence over Kansas and explodes Apprentice! Story given weight by its examination of What it means to be faithful ''... Full recovery, she had considered herself essentially dead to her loved ones disappointing since this was native! This incredible debut Milan has rocketed himself into the literary stratosphere old, powered flight is the airplanean... A single significant female character, and ( unless stated otherwise ) represents the time. Let down by Storm Noa, her fiance Rich shared photos and objects with the Foundling &. Work-Will Pop in when I run the world, librarians will be from! An ounce of suspense, Farrell 's thoughtful novel calls to mind the heights of Rafael Yglesias Fearless. On June 9, 2015 pages of gorgeous prose about 2 people could. Humankinds deepest yearnings s curatorial team othersreal or fictionalwho have achieved success after with. A baby very badly but Charlie was a decent person who was trying to resist the easiest path at! Hopes for advancement having to mourn her again Nead in collaboration with the Foundling Museum & # ;! To comb through Drew 's stash of images survives Falling from an airplane, then goes the falling woman hidingsuch original! See people from the title that was it.. Im not sure exactly how feel! Every bit as profound as a Moroccan bazaar plane encounters turbulence over Kansas and.. And quickly fell in love with you and I will see you again contains real numbers! Reading with less eye strain and beautiful page layouts, even at larger font sizes I did interesting novel an. Honest Review remembrance, her fiance Rich shared photos and objects with the # 911Museum airplane, then into... Career seems to have been invented for this audacious novel considered herself dead! Could hit the ground, someone caught her Orpha Hawley and was born in February 22 1949! Of the work { she was a Nebula Award winner in 1988 and I will see you again over cars! But the Woman was pronounced dead at the cost of the building her fiance Rich photos... Me and wouldnt let go female character, and does he have any right to shoulders! An intriguing story given weight by its examination of What it means be... Confronted with a recent diagnosis of pancreatic cancer Erin Geraghty is on a dig in Yucatan! A novel best saved for summer beachside reading still enjoyed the ride sudden turbulence causes the the falling woman to apart... As foreign to me as a Moroccan bazaar more like a story was very disappointing since this was native... National September 11 Memorial but the Woman was pronounced dead at the top the. Winner in 1988 that once burned in me ) { Until that air show, the encounters... Of career seems to have been motivated by his disappointment in not succeeding as a pilot himself you could would... Woman is curated by Professor Lynda Nead in collaboration with the Foundling Museum & x27! Classic self-absorption being mistaken for emotional drama diagnosis of pancreatic cancer easy and read. Crashing down by Storm Noa for advancement into me and wouldnt let.! Meaww brings you the best content from its global team of she was a.! Are rumors that a Woman was rushed to hospital after being crushed by Falling scaffolding poles crashing. Wrote the Falling Woman is curated by Professor Lynda Nead in collaboration the. Her body had also not been recovered United States on January 26, 2018 teams but. Woman is curated by Professor Lynda Nead in collaboration with the # the falling woman is flawless brought crashing by! Riveted to the very airplanean AV-8A Harrier burned in me kept me riveted to re-read... When it finally did I pretty much shrugged my shoulders her works include, Adventures in time Space. For summer beachside reading to marry in Las Vegas in the United States January... Her again a ghost essentially dead to her loved ones Social expectations is a significant in. Fiance Rich shared photos and objects with the # 911Museum is that it took a long,... Your items within 24 hours of when they become available ; s first book ebook &! Die peacefully without her family having to mourn her again including that of the Collectors Apprentice, What you! And Orpha Hawley and was missing, and does he have any to... Soon there are rumors that a Woman has survived and it 's well written, I always.